Just got back from Chicago, where I attended Architecture & Design World. The event was great. it had many interesting talks and sessions  which I'll blog about in  few of the following posts (Also I'll upload the slides from my sessions later this week). One session however, was very disappointing for me, Ivar Jacobson's Keynote on "Next Generation Process with Essential Modeling".

I was really looking forward for this keynote; After all Ivar is one of the "Three Amigos", father of use cases and all. Also I had the chance to attend a couple of his presentations several years ago and he had a very interesting and convincing appearances at those times. Unfortunetly this session was nothing like those previous events.
Ivar talked about his new methodology. The basic idea behind the essential software process is (in my opinion) correct. Instead of big bang prescribed processes - it is better to tailor a process from a set of practices to get something that fits the organization/project at hand. It might be a little unnerving to hear this from one of the people who brought (upon) us the RUP, but, I guess it is good to see people who are constantly learning.

The problem was that while the main idea can be summed up in one line (see above) Ivar went on fro the better part of the hour to explain how cool it was that his base set of practices comes on a set of que cards that can be sorted and arranged. He also went on to explain the game board (or something to that effect) where you can lay different cards to both describe your current process as well as the bunch of practices you want to use for your future process.
If that wasn't enough, when he (briefly) shown us the cards that talk about the architecture and architecture description practices the advice/guidance there was very mediocre and general
I expected much more from someone of the stature of Ivar Jacobson.
On the up-side this was only one keynote and the other sessions I listened to where much better - as I already said, I'll blog about few of them in upcoming posts.

 
Monday, July 30, 2007 9:49:53 PM (GMT Standard Time, UTC+00:00)
Hey Arnon,

I gave up on Ivar and company. All talk, no implementation...

http://realworldsa.dotnetdevelopersjournal.com/essuptoiconix.htm

Tad
Comments are closed.